Best Worst-Case Scenario: Breakup?

Story of developments here. In this light we should wonder whether the best option from the Western perspective might be for Syria to in fact break apart, with an Assad controlled state from Damascus to the North, and a Sunni state further to the east. There’s a few advantages from the Western perspective.

1. It might be a relatively quick way to end the current bloodshed.

2. The Sunni state, being a weak state ensconced between Alawite Al-Assad Syria and Iraq, might be a lot more amenable to Western support and policy preferences than if it came to power triumphantly in a successful revolution. Similarly, the presence of an external threat might prevent civil war.

3. The Al-Assad state, , being located between Turkey and Sunni Syria, would need constant support from Iran, preoccupying them with a potentially grinding problem. (On the other hand, the creation of a second Iranian satellite above Lebanon may also not be an appealing prospect.)

4. For Israel in particular, the advantages might be significant. Syria as a foe would be fragmented and amenable to Israeli policies of divide and conquer. What is more, pressure to abandon the Golan might diminish dramatically. Who to return it to? The population of the Golan on both sides of the border is actually Druze, not Sunni, who have a history of being pro-Assad. But given the existence of a ‘good’, pro-Western Sunni Syria, clearly there would be no pressure on Israel to return the Golan to the ‘bad’ Syria.

Advertisements

One thought on “Best Worst-Case Scenario: Breakup?

  1. The problem with this suggestion is that the different ethnic and religious groups in Syria do not live in geographically distinct, ethnically and religiously homogeneous areas. This is especially the case for the major cities, but it applies to most rural areas as well. The last attempt to split off a religiously homogeneous area of Syria – carried out by the French – resulted in the creation of “Christian” Lebanon, and that hardly worked out as planned. Westerners do not have a good track record when it comes to drawing up Middle Eastern borders.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s